Asbury Theological Seminary Removed by UMC — Just Years After the Historic Revival Captured the World’s Attention

By Pastor Duke Taber Jun 26, 2026 0CategoryDenominationsTag - News

By Pastor Duke Taber

In This Article

A century-old evangelical seminary in Wilmore, Kentucky, says it is standing firm on biblical convictions after being officially removed from the United Methodist Church’s list of approved schools for ordination candidates — a decision that has drawn both sorrow and resolute defiance from the evangelical world.

The announcement came Thursday, June 25, 2026, when Asbury Theological Seminary disclosed that the University Senate of the United Methodist Church had voted to delist the institution from its approved schools of theology. At the center of the dispute are the UMC’s revised 2024 Social Principles on human sexuality and marriage — standards that Asbury says are incompatible with its own biblical convictions.

The timing carries a weight that no one in the Church can ignore. In February 2023, just a few miles from the seminary’s front steps, the small town of Wilmore, Kentucky, was flooded by the most widely-watched spiritual outpouring in a generation.

The Revival That Shook the World

To understand the full weight of this moment, you have to go back to February 8, 2023.

What began as a routine chapel service at Asbury University — a separate but neighboring institution sharing the same Wesleyan roots — suddenly became something no one planned. Students stayed after the service to pray and worship. They didn’t leave. That evening there were a couple of hundred students still gathered in Hughes Auditorium. The next day, more came. Then thousands. Then tens of thousands.

“The wind blows where it wishes, and you hear its sound, but you do not know where it comes from or where it goes. So it is with everyone who is born of the Spirit.” — John 3:8, NKJV

The revival quickly spread on social media, particularly among Generation Z. By February 15, the hashtag “asburyrevival” had accumulated over 24 million views on TikTok, climbing to 63 million by February 18. By the time it concluded, the outpouring had drawn an estimated 50,000 to 70,000 visitors to Wilmore — a town of just 6,000 — representing more than 200 academic institutions and multiple countries.

News outlets around the world reported on the Asbury Outpouring. The New York Times called it “‘Woodstock’ for Christians: Revival Draws Thousands to Kentucky Town.” Time magazine asked what Asbury’s revival said about America’s need for connection.

The outpouring became a defining moment for revival watchers, a fresh point of hope in an era when many had given up on the institutional church. What began as a regularly scheduled chapel service turned into a 16-day outpouring of the Holy Spirit, with pilgrims of all stripes — celebrities, reporters, musicians, and well-known pastors — descending upon Wilmore as news attracted worldwide attention.

Asbury Theological Seminary — directly across the street from Asbury University — opened its own chapel, auditorium, and gymnasium to accommodate the overflow crowds that descended on that small Kentucky town.

Now, little more than three years later, the seminary faces a starkly different chapter. You can read more about the history of revival in America on America’s Defining Spiritual Awakenings and The Tent Revival Movement Sweeping America in 2026.

The Delisting: What Happened

Asbury Theological Seminary, a multi-denominational, evangelical seminary rooted in the Wesleyan tradition and serving over 75 different denominations, was informed that the University Senate of the United Methodist Church has decided to remove the institution from the list of approved schools of theology for the preparation of candidates for ordination in the UMC. The seminary was first approved in 1946 by The Methodist Church, one of the predecessor bodies of the UMC. Beginning in 1981, it received approval from the UMC for the education of candidates for ordained ministry.

A statement from the UMC’s Commission on Theological Education determined that Asbury’s published ethos statement is not compatible with the Social Principles of the United Methodist Church. In addition, the UMC noted that Asbury does not have a full-time United Methodist faculty member who consistently teaches required United Methodist history, doctrine, and polity.

Asbury was not alone. Four theological schools in total were removed by the University Senate from the list of approved schools for United Methodist candidates for ministry: Asbury Theological Seminary, Luther Seminary in St. Paul, Minnesota, Northeastern Seminary at Roberts Wesleyan University in Rochester, New York, and Palmer Theological Seminary of Eastern University in St. Davids, Pennsylvania. In February 2026, the University Senate received official notification that Palmer wished to decline its invitation and be removed. In May 2026, Luther Seminary also declined the invitation for review and asked to be removed. Northeastern’s removal was related to faculty requirements and online delivery standards.

But the delisting of Asbury was different in kind — and far more significant. This was not a school quietly stepping away. This was a confrontation.

Asbury’s Response: Standing Firm

Asbury President Dr. David F. Watson issued a clear and measured statement that left no ambiguity about where the seminary stands.

“We understand the Senate’s governing role within the United Methodist Church and acknowledge its decision. However, this outcome reflects a determination made by the UMC rather than a shared resolution. We engaged fully and faithfully in the process and honored every request from the Senate in a timely manner. We were forthcoming with the requested documents and information. Throughout the process, we were honest and clear about our doctrinal and ethical standards, even when those differed from the recently amended Social Principles of The UMC.”

Watson described the final decision as unilateral, saying their focus remains “steadfast on our unchanging calling.” The crux of the theological divide was stated plainly:

“The Senate’s requirements, particularly those related to the UMC’s 2024 Social Principles concerning ‘Human Sexuality’ and ‘Marriage,’ are not aligned with Asbury Theological Seminary’s institutional ethos and the historic witness of the Christian faith. We affirm marriage as sanctioned by God, which joins one man and one woman in a single, exclusive union for life, as delineated in Scripture, and provides the sole context for sexual intimacy, helping to ensure the blessings of that relationship as God intended.” — Dr. David F. Watson, President, Asbury Theological Seminary

“Our theological commitments, including our commitment to Scripture, remain unchanged. As an independent, multi-denominational seminary in the Wesleyan tradition, we have remained steadfast for more than a century in teaching the unchanging truth of orthodox Christianity. Our mission and values are the same today as they have been for more than a century.”

What Changed at the UMC

The roots of this conflict go back to the UMC’s 2024 General Conference, a watershed moment for the denomination. The UMC made headlines in 2024 when its General Conference attendees voted to redefine marriage as a sacrament between two people of faith rather than between a man and a woman. Attendees also voted to remove a portion of the church code that had declared the practice of homosexuality as incompatible with Christian teaching.

This change was notable because two years before the Global Methodist Church launched in 2022, departing United Methodist congregations had already begun exiting over these very issues. The Global Methodist Church — a theologically conservative breakaway denomination — continues to recognize Asbury Theological Seminary as an approved institution.

The denomination’s social principles were revised during the 2024 General Conference, when delegates voted to remove from the UMC’s rule book a statement added in 1972 that called homosexuality “incompatible with Christian teaching.”

This is the theological pivot that made Asbury’s continued approval impossible. A seminary that has held to the authority of Scripture for over a century could not sign off on doctrinal standards that contradict it.

The Practical Impact — and Who It Affects

The immediate practical consequences are real but limited in scope. Currently, approximately 9% of the student population at Asbury Theological Seminary identifies as UMC. Current students and any UMC-affiliated student seeking ordination within the UMC who begins coursework at Asbury Theological Seminary by Fall 2026 will be grandfathered into the UMC.

Today, thousands of Asbury Theological Seminary graduates flourish in every state, on every continent, and in every time zone, reaching the world through evangelism, missions, church planting, preaching, teaching, and counseling. Watson noted that more than 4,000 living Asbury alumni affiliated with the UMC have served churches worldwide.

The United Methodist bishop of the region where Asbury is located addressed the mixed emotions the decision was expected to prompt. “Many in our conference will receive this news with disappointment and sadness,” wrote Bishop David Graves, leader of the UMC Kentucky-Tennessee Episcopal Area. “I share those feelings. For many clergy and laity across Kentucky and Tennessee, Asbury is more than an institution. It is a place where faith was deepened, callings were clarified, friendships were formed, and lives were changed.”

Meanwhile, voices from outside the UMC were less conflicted. Mark Tooley, president of the conservative Institute on Religion and Democracy, stated: “Asbury Seminary is the largest theologically Wesleyan seminary in the world. It will easily outlast the shrinking United Methodist Church.”

This decision does not impact the seminary’s institutional accreditation. Asbury Theological Seminary holds 10-year accreditations from the Association of Theological Schools (ATS) and the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission on Colleges (SACSCOC). It remains an approved theological institution for the Global Methodist Church, among other denominations.

A Broader Pattern of Division

This moment cannot be separated from the wider story of mainline Protestant decline and the fracturing of the Methodist world. What is happening with Asbury is part of a larger arc — the fork in the road between denominations that follow cultural trends and institutions that hold to the historic Christian faith.

For students of revival history, there is a painful irony here. The very place that hosted one of the most powerful spiritual outpourings of the 21st century — drawing Gen Z students from across the world back to repentance, prayer, and the presence of God — now finds itself on the wrong side of a denominational line that has moved in the opposite direction.

But here is what is worth noting: Asbury Theological Seminary founded in 1923 has weathered denominational controversies before. It did not cave. It did not negotiate its doctrinal positions. It told the truth and let the UMC make its own decision.

That is exactly what faithfulness looks like. You may want to explore related coverage on Standing For Truth in an Age of Spin and America’s 10 Most Impactful Spiritual Awakenings That Shaped a Nation. For insight into what the Bible says about holding firm to the faith regardless of institutional pressure, see How Worship Fuels Revival: Lessons from Church History and Scripture.

What This Means for the Church

This is a moment that calls for clarity, not hand-wringing.

Seminaries exist to train ministers of the Gospel — not ministers of cultural consensus. When an institution refuses to compromise the biblical definition of marriage and human sexuality, it is doing exactly what it was built to do.

The Asbury Theological Seminary’s mission since 1923 has been to “prepare and send forth well-trained, sanctified, Spirit-filled, evangelistic ministers to spread scriptural holiness around the world.” That mission doesn’t change because a denominational Senate changes its social principles.

What we are watching unfold is the continued sorting of American Christianity. Those who hold to Scripture are finding their places in institutions that do the same. Those who are willing to redefine what Scripture says will find a home elsewhere.

The UMC loses far more in this transaction than Asbury does.

As Spirit-filled believers who believe in both the authority of Scripture and the move of the Holy Spirit, we should be watching this moment carefully — and praying for the students, faculty, and alumni of Asbury Theological Seminary who are navigating this transition with grace and conviction.

The fire that fell in 2023 is still burning. No denominational senate can extinguish it.

“So they called them and commanded them not to speak at all nor teach in the name of Jesus. But Peter and John answered and said to them, ‘Whether it is right in the sight of God to listen to you more than to God, you judge. For we cannot but speak the things which we have seen and heard.'” — Acts 4:18–20, NKJV

Related Resources from AnsweredFaith.com:

Download: Deepen your understanding of what Scripture says about revival, worship, and standing firm in the faith. Explore the 13 Bible Study Lessons on Worship available now at AnsweredFaith.com.

Sources

Charisma Magazine — “Asbury Theological Seminary Removed by the UMC Just Years After the Historic Revival Captured the World’s Attention” — Abby Trivett, June 25, 2026. mycharisma.com
Asbury Theological Seminary Official Press Release — “Asbury Theological Seminary Addresses Recent United Methodist Church Decision” — June 25, 2026. asburyseminary.edu
Baptist News Global — “UMC removes Asbury and 3 others as approved seminaries” — June 25, 2026. baptistnews.com
Religion News Service — “Asbury Theological Seminary cut by United Methodist Church over same-sex marriage issue” — June 25, 2026. religionnews.com
UM News — “Leaders drop Asbury from approved seminaries” — June 25, 2026. umnews.org
Church Leaders — “Asbury Seminary Removed From United Methodist Church’s Approved Ordination School List” — June 25, 2026. churchleaders.com
Wikipedia — “2023 Asbury revival.” en.wikipedia.org
Asbury University — “The Outpouring Story of Revival.” asbury.edu

Denominations

What Is the Roman Catholic Church?

Last updated: June 2026 By Pastor Duke Taber Almost everyone has a Catholic somewhere in their story. A grandmother who prayed the rosary at the kitchen…

By Pastor Duke TaberJun 24, 2026

Christianity

The World Came to America for the World Cup and Found Unexpected Kindness

Last updated: June 2026 By Pastor Duke Taber Something surprising has unfolded across America this summer, and it has very little to do with the score…

By Pastor Duke TaberJun 25, 2026